The 12-time Grammy Winner’s first toss into the crowd took a while to come back as the person who caught the ball seemed reluctant to give it back. That fan’s throw sailed over Simon’s head. After retrieving the ball, Simon tossed it into the crowd again. This time, the return throw landed short and bounced past the singer. On his third attempt, Simon finally found a catcher who successfully tossed back a strike that landed in his mitt.